A Barron’s reader (via controlledgreed.com) has written the financial weekly with the report card of the stock picks of the 2006 roundtable. I am copying those results here, along with links leading to detailed portfolios of all the stock recommendations by the 2007 roundtable.

Scott Black: Made 28.5% on 6 picks. One lost money.

Abby Joseph Cohen: Made 17.6% on 6 picks. All made money.

Mark Faber: Made 32.9% on 12 picks. All made money. Two good shorts.

Mario Gabelli: Made 20.1% on 11 picks. All made money.

Bill Gross: Made 17.3% on 4 picks. All made money.

Fred Hickey: Made 4.9% on 4 picks. One lost money. Three good shorts.

Archie MacAllaster: Lost 13.3% on 7 picks. Two lost money.

John Neff: Lost 8.7% on 4 picks. Two lost money.

Art Samberg: Made 30.1% on 8 picks. Two lost money.

Oscar Schafer: Made 34.4% on 5 picks. All made money.

Meryl Witmer: Made 61.1% on 5 picks. All made money.

Felix Zulauf made 27.4% on eight picks. One lost money.

Omid Malekan